Comment

Which facts?

Five errors in 'Realism needs today's facts'

Comment on Rosenow (2026), 'Realism needs today's facts', Bright Spots (Substack), 1 November 2026, a review of Helm (2026), Climate Realism.

Comment

Five claims checked against the sources the review itself links.

Abstract

Jan Rosenow’s review of Dieter Helm’s Climate Realism is titled ‘Realism needs today’s facts’. We classified its 44 factual claims against the sources it links. Five central claims, on temperature, electricity bills, the size of a future energy system, prices and the cost of solar power, are overstated or mislabelled. Each is corrected by a source the review links or by Rosenow’s own figures.

Versions

VersionDateWhat
Working draft1 November 2026CommentPDF